|
Sleep Pattern And Daytime Functions In Italian Adolescents
FLAVIA GIANNOTTI FLAVIA CORTESI
Center of Pediatric Sleep Disorders
Dept. Develop. Neurology and Psychiatry
University "La Sapienza" Rome, Italy
tudies carried out in Europe and North
America have suggested that adolescents
experience insufficient sleep with increased
level in daytime sleepiness and negative
effects on daytime functioning. Since ethnic
and socio-cultural influences may affect sleep
and few studies exist of young people's
sleeping habits and difficulties in Italy, we
carried out a questionnaire-based survey of
sleep habits and problems on a sample of
adolescents 14 to 20 years old representative
of public secondary school population in
Italy. The response rate was 87%. The final
cleaned sampled population consisted of 6632
(3987 F- 2645 M) Data were collected through
self administered Sleep Questionnaire for
Adolescents by Carskadon in a classroom
situation. It includes items about sleep/wake
behaviors and the following scales: Sleepiness
(SS), Sleep Disturbances (SD), Anxiety (ANX),
Depression (DEP), Owl/Lark (M/E), Substance
Use (SUBS). All girls were post-menarchal and
all boys showed evident of marked pubertal
changes. Results are based on
cross-tabulations by sex and age group (14-15;
15-16; 16-17; 17-18; >18 yrs.). Statistical
significances were calculated by means of
ANOVA and chi-square. Furthermore, to identify
predictors of self-perception of poor sleep
quality and use of substances to promote
sleep, logistic regressions were performed.
As expected, ANOVA results confirmed
significant changes in sleep pattern with
chronological age: a reduction of sleep time
(p<.0001); a tendency to go to bed later
(p<.0001) and less regularly with age
(p<.0001), boys more often than girls
(p<.0001). Parental involvement, both at
bedtime and risetime, decreased as adolescents
got older (bedtime from 3% at 15 yrs to 0.9%
at 18 yrs; risetime from 43% at 15 yrs to 32%
at 18 yrs). This is different from the report
of Carskadon which found that parental
influence diminishes at bedtime but becomes
more important on waking in the morning.
Difficulties in falling asleep were reported
in 21% of students, without gender
differences, but girls suffered more from
nighttime wakings (11,5% vs 8,1% p<.001). As a
measure of sleep schedule regularity we
computed the difference between weekend and
school nights bedtime (BDS). An irregular
sleep schedules (BDS higher than 3 hours) was
found in 25% of students, boys more often than
in girls (14,7% vs 11%).
Regarding sociodemographic factors while
socio-economic (SES) level of parents was not
correlated to sleep problems, we found that
adolescents from non-intact families (8.6%)
had more sleep irregularity (BDS 131 vs 115
mins; p<.001). Small differences in some sleep
habits among geographical region were found.
Students living in the South went to bed
significantly later (20 mins) but their sleep
schedules are more regular compared to those
living in the North and Center. Students
living in urban areas showed more sleep
irregular sleep and tend to sleep less either
in school or in weekend nights.
Moreover, we examined the relationship between
subjective evaluation of poor sleep quality,
their sleep habits and symptoms of sleep
disturbances. The "Do you consider yourself to
be a poor sleeper?" question was used to
define sleep quality. Of 6632 students, 19.6%
considered themselves as poor sleeper,
significantly more girls than boys (21% vs
17%; p<.001). Self-perception of poor sleep
tended to increase with age in both sexes
(14-15 yrs 15%, 15-16 yrs 18%, 16-17 yrs 19%,
17-18 yrs 20% >18 yrs 22.3%; Pearson
chi-square 25.5; df=4; p<.001). To better
identify variables related to a
self-evaluation of poor sleep quality,
logistic regression analysis was performed,
which showed the following independent
variables (female sex, sleep onset insomnia,
nightwakings either brief and multiple or
prolonged, depression, anxiety and evening
phase preference) in association to
self-perception of poor sleep. Parasomnias and
erratic sleep schedules, although more
frequent in poor sleepers, were not
statistically significant in relation to
self-reported poor sleep quality Sleep length
did not contribute to self-perception of poor
sleep.
We also investigated the use of sleeping pills
in Italian adolescents to determine the
prevalence and to identify associated factors.
Results showed that 4% of students had used
medication to help themselves to sleep at
least once during the last six months, but
only 1.3% had regularly taken sleeping pills.
Girls were more prevalent users than males
(5.3% vs 2.04%; p<.001). Consumption was
related and tended to increase with age
(Pearson chi-square df=4; p<.001). In general
the increase was considerably larger for girls
than boys and this sex difference was found in
all age groups. Ansiolitic benzodiazepines
were used by 44.2% of students, while 10% of
them had used aspirin or NSAID and 33% had
taken herbs, to improve sleep. Finally,
homeopathic remedies were used in 2.6% of
students while 6.5% of them did not specify
the type of substance used. Professional help
for sleeping problems had been sought by 2.5%
of all the sample. Ansiolitic benzodiazepines
were prescribed by general practitioners in
58.6% of cases, while NSAID were suggested by
parents in 17% of them of self-prescribed in
25% of students. In order to determine which
independent variables were significantly
associated with the condition of using
substance to promote sleep, logistic
regression analysis was performed. Seven
independent variables (female sex, living in
urban area, multiple midnight awakenings,
headache related to sleep, depression, anxiety
and consumption of psychoactive substances)
were statistically significant in relation to
the use of sleeping pills. Sleep onset
insomnia, irregular sleep patterns as well as
partial arousal disorders were not
statistically significant in relation to use
of sleeping pills.
Moreover ANOVA results showed an association
between poor self-reported school achievement
and increased complain of daytime sleepiness
(p<.001), greater use of caffeine, alcohol,
and tobacco (p<.001), sleep problems (p<.001),
evening phase delay preference (p<.001),
anxiety (p<.001) and depressive mood (p<.01).
We found that, of the small percentage of
students who went to bed later on school
nights than on weekends, most of them across
all age groups (57% at 14 yrs to 37% at 18
yrs) had this late bedtime because of the
habit of doing homework in the evening.
Furthermore, students who referred attention
problems at school slept less either in school
(462 vs 477 mins; p<.001) or in weekend nights
(526 vs 543 mins; p<.001), had more irregular
bedtime (140 vs 109 mins; p<.001) and
significant higher scores in all scales but
M/E scale where they obtained lower scores. In
order to investigate the influence of school
starting time on sleep and daytime behavior,
we compared sleep pattern for late vs early
starting schools. Despite the small difference
in school start time in Italy (7.45 vs 8.45
am) across all age groups, we found that
students who attended the school with earliest
start time had more irregular sleep schedules
(p<.001) complained of daytime sleepiness (55%
vs 44%, p<.01), tended to fall asleep at
school more frequently (9.5% vs 6%; p<.05)
were at risk of increased use of stimulants
(p<.001) and reported more frequently poor
academic performance (7% vs 4%; p<.05).
Of the whole sample, 88% across all ages and
without gender difference, reported having had
some accidents (at home, at school, driving).
The increased vulnerability to accidents
showed a positive correlation to daytime
sleepiness (r=.15 p<.0001) increased use of
stimulants and tobacco (r=.18 p<.001) and
mainly to sleep problems (r=.25 p<.00001) and
to anxiety (r=.18 p<.001).
Our data confirmed the presence also in
Italian adolescents of unhealthy sleeping
habits and difficulties more prevalent in late
adolescence. According with other studies,
adolescent poor sleepers showed significant
differences in daytime feelings and mood,
complaining also poor school achievement. Poor
sleep self-perception occurs with sufficient
frequency in healthy adolescent, and is
significantly more prevalent in girls. However
most of them do not seek help for their sleep.
In contrast they were more prone to use
substance to help themselves to sleep.
Although International comparisons are
difficult to establish because of differences
in legislation, our results are similar to
other adolescent studies. Despite the use of
medications to enhance sleep were not very
common in Italian adolescents, the tendency,
that increases with age, to use a chemical
solution may persist in adult life and become
a risk factor for habitual use. Since all
these topics, with its possible public health
significance, has largely been ignored in
Italy, much more attention must be paid to
this problem in order to prevent the negative
impact of poor sleep habits on daytime
functioning also in our country.
|